FREQUENTLY ASKED QUESTIONS

Below you will learn more about our custom cakes and find the answers to our most frequently asked questions.


What is the pricing for custom cakes?

Our cakes start at $6/serving and tiered cakes at $7/serving. Pricing depends greatly on design which is charged by the hour.

Do you have an order minimum?

We have a minimum order of $100 for any custom cake. Delivery fees do not count towards the minimum.

Do you deliver?

Yes! Delivery is $2 per mile and any on-site set up or floral arrangements are charged by the hour. You are also welcome to pick up your cake one day in advance.

How do I order a custom cake?

Please fill out the contact form here and we can start a conversation about what you’re looking for and if we’re available for your event date.

What does the ordering process look like?

Once we have discussed details and if you would like to move forward, we will send over a contract and a 25% deposit is required to secure your event date. The order must be finalized and the remaining 75% paid in full at least 7 days in advance of the event.

When should I order my cake?

Our availability is limited so we recommend reaching out as soon as you know what you’d like for your cake in order to secure your date. If you’re curious if your date is still available, please reach out and we will let you know!

Do you offer tastings?

We offer $25 tasting boxes for pick up where you can try four cake flavors of your choice. You can preorder a tasting box on the online shop and we will reach out to schedule a time for pick up.

What exactly is a serving size?

Each cake slice has four layers of cake and three layers of filling. We go by industry standard cake serving sizes, specifically Wilton Cake’s serving chart. Party servings are approximately 1½ x 2 x 5 inches and wedding servings are approximately 1 x 2 x 5 inches. Keep in mind that these servings might be smaller than the slices you are used to; consider ordering more cake if you would like larger servings or leftovers.

Do you make cakes for dietary restrictions?

While we did in the past, we unfortunately do not offer cakes for dietary restrictions. However, we highly recommend these bakeries that do:

Botanical Bakeshop (vegan and GF)
Sweet Bree’s (GF)
Ellen’s Fine Goods (vegan and GF)

Do you have offerings for dessert tables?

Yes, we do offer a selection of desserts for dessert tables:

Cupcakes: $3.5 each
Variety of cookies: $2 each
Brown butter brownies: $4 each
Shortbread: $1.5 each
Vanilla bean cheesecake bars: $3 each

Do you offer sheet cakes?

Yes. Sheet cakes are $5/serving and can be made in various sizes to accommodate your guest count.

Do you offer rental cake stands and platters?

We do not offer rental equipment at this time. We recommend looking at various home goods stores for cake stands and platters or asking your venue if they have options for rent.

What size cake stand should I get if I would like to use one?

We recommend a sturdy cake stand that is at least 2 inches in diameter larger than the bottom tier of your cake. Cake is surprisingly heavy so it’s best to ensure the stand is stable and won’t topple over from the weight.

Do you make fondant covered cakes or decorations?

We specialize in buttercream-only cakes and designs and do not use fondant to cover cakes or make decorations. If there is a fondant decoration you really love and want to use, feel free to purchase it and we will happily affix it to your cake. Etsy is a great place to find fondant decorations.


Holler Box
Holler Box